At dinner, my sibling and I were both reaching across the table.
A plate slid off the edge and broke on the kitchen floor. Nobody saw whose elbow it was. The adult said my name right away. Then the adult handed me the dustpan. I thought the adult was already sure it was me. I looked at my sibling for a second, hoping they would say something. I didn’t say it might have been my sibling’s elbow. It would have sounded like an excuse.
“Sorry,” I said while I swept. Saying sorry was quicker than arguing. I checked the floor twice for tiny pieces. I wanted the adult to see I was being careful. When I sat back down, I tried to remember where my elbow had been. I couldn’t tell, so I decided it was probably mine.
I kept my elbows tight against my sides for the rest of dinner, in case something else fell. At breakfast the next day, I pushed my cup into the middle of the table. That way nothing could fall off my side of the table.
A few days later, we were in the car. The adult looked in the mirror and said, “Who left a wrapper on the floor back here?” There was one by my foot and another one under my sibling’s seat. The adult was looking at me in the mirror.
“Me,” I said. I said it before checking whose wrapper it was, because it was easier than waiting for the adult to ask me.
“Okay, put them in the bag,” the adult said, and handed back a plastic bag. I picked up both wrappers, even the one under my sibling’s seat. I didn’t want to leave anything on the floor for the adult to point at.
A bit later, still in the car, the adult said, “Did you touch my phone charger? It’s not in the cup holder.”
“I don’t think so,” I said. Then I opened my backpack and looked inside, so the adult could see I had really checked.
On Saturday, I went to a friend’s house. We were playing in the living room when the adult at my friend’s house called from the kitchen, “Who left the back door open? The dog got out.” I hadn’t gone anywhere near the back door. “Sorry, it was probably me,” I called back. I said it before anyone asked me, because at home it’s usually me who gets blamed.
My friend looked at me. “You didn’t go near the door.” I shrugged. I hoped the friend would just let it go. I didn’t know how to explain why I’d said it.
The adult at my friend’s house came in and said, “It’s okay, nobody’s in trouble. The dog’s back already.” I said sorry again, more quietly, because the first sorry didn’t feel like enough.
I checked the back door twice before I sat down again, so no one could say it was me. The next week at dinner, a cup tipped over. It was my sibling’s cup. I was already up getting the paper towels before the adult said anything, because I figured my name was coming next. When something spills or breaks, I look at my own hands first.
I’m already saying sorry before I know what happened.