On Saturday morning, the cookie jar was empty.
I had walked past the jar twice and never lifted the lid, because the adult had said the cookies were for after dinner. The adult opened the jar, looked inside, and then looked at me.
“Did you eat all the cookies?”
“No. It wasn’t me.”
I looked right at the adult when I said it, so they would see I wasn’t lying. “There were six in here yesterday,” the adult said.
“It wasn’t me,” I said again, slower, in case the adult hadn’t understood me the first time.
The adult sighed. I watched the adult’s face and hoped the adult would believe me. “If you tell me the truth, I won’t be mad.”
“I’ll tell you next time,” I said, even though there was nothing to tell. I wanted the talking to be over. After that, I went into my sibling’s room. Then I saw cookie crumbs on my sibling’s bed. I didn’t show the adult the crumbs. Showing the crumbs would sound like I was blaming my sibling to get out of trouble. I pulled my bedroom door shut.
At dinner, the adult scooped ice cream for everyone. I said I didn’t want any, so nobody would think I was asking for more sweets after the cookies.
On Monday, I was buckled in the back seat, looking out the window. My sibling started to cry, and the adult looked at me in the mirror.
“What did you do?”
“I didn’t do anything.”
“They’re crying. Say sorry.” I had seen my sibling bump their knee on the seat when the car stopped.
“But they just bumped their knee…”
“I can’t listen right now, I’m driving. Say sorry.” I turned around and said sorry to my sibling. I said it fast, so the adult would stop watching me in the rearview mirror. For the rest of the car ride, I kept my hands flat on my knees where the adult could see them.
On Wednesday, the class was working quietly when someone near me whispered. The adult turned around from the board.
“Who is talking?” Nobody said anything. The adult looked at our table and wrote my name on the board. I raised my hand.
“Not now, I’m teaching.”
I put my hand down. I thought the adult might not want to hear me anyway. All through the lesson, I kept the sentence ready in my head: “It wasn’t me, I was looking at my pencil.” The adult never asked me if it was me.
At the end of the day, I took a long time packing my backpack so I could tell the adult it wasn’t me when the room was empty. The adult was busy talking to someone at the door and didn’t look at me. I stood by my desk for a bit and didn’t say anything, then went to line up with everyone else.
I kept hoping the adult would look over so I could say it. Last week, at home, the adult called from the kitchen. “Who left the milk out?”
I hadn’t even been in the kitchen. I said, “I’ll put it away,” and went in and did it. I thought the adult might not believe me if I said I hadn’t been in the kitchen. I said it in a happy voice, so it wouldn’t sound like I was angry about it. So I stopped saying it wasn’t me.
Saying it never changed what the adult thought.