One afternoon, I got in the car and started talking before I even buckled my seatbelt.
“Some people in my class kept tossing my eraser over my head, and I kept jumping for it, but they wouldn’t give it back! They were laughing the whole time!”
The adult glanced at me in the mirror and said, “Hey, I can hear that tone. Take a breath and say it again nicely.” I stopped talking right in the middle of the sentence. I didn’t know which part of my voice had sounded wrong. I started over, but quieter. I left out the part where the kids laughed, because that was where my voice went up.
“That doesn’t sound very nice of them,” the adult said. “You can tell me anything, you just have to say it nicely.” I said I would try to say it nicely. I wanted to ask the adult what nicely sounded like. I didn’t ask, in case that sounded wrong too.
“Did you get your eraser back?” the adult asked.
“Yes,” I said. I hadn’t. Telling the truth meant telling the eraser story again, and I didn’t want to listen to myself try again. I pressed my lips together for the rest of the ride so nothing else would come out.
On Saturday, I was walking next to the cart in the grocery store, telling the adult about something funny that happened on the bus. I was using my hands, and I was almost at the best part.
“Easy,” the adult said. “Indoor voice, please.” I dropped my voice until it was almost a whisper and told the best part really slowly. I wanted to be quiet enough this time.
The adult leaned down toward me. I hoped the adult hadn’t heard me, so I wouldn’t have to say it again. “Sorry, what was that?”
“Nothing,” I said. “It wasn’t important.” The story wasn’t funny that quietly, and I didn’t want to say it louder. For the rest of the trip, I only answered questions.
“Do you want apples?”
“Yes.” I figured a short answer couldn’t have a bad tone.
That night in the bath, I told the eraser story to my knees poking out of the water. I tried a low voice, then a slow voice, then a voice that sounded like I was smiling. I was trying to figure out what sounded nice, but the low voice, the slow voice, and the smiling voice all sounded the same to me.
At bedtime, I asked, “Why do I have to go to bed now?”
“Tone,” the adult said, not mad, just tired.
“Sorry,” I said. I didn’t know what I’d done, but saying sorry was the quickest way to make it stop.
The adult leaned on the door frame. I wanted to tell the adult that I still didn’t have my eraser, but I didn’t know how to say it nicely. “Anything else you want to tell me before sleep?”
“No.” I didn’t have the nice voice ready yet, and I didn’t want to start without it. The adult walked over from the door frame to my bed. The adult kissed my head and said, “Love you.” I whispered, “Love you too,” in the softest voice I had. Nobody could say my tone was bad if it was that soft.
I say things in my head first. Most of it stays in there.