On Sunday the adult picked me up from the other house.
I got in the back seat and buckled up.
“Did you have fun?” the adult asked.
We had made pancakes and watched a movie with a dog in it. I said, “It was okay.” I didn’t want the adult to think the other house was better. I had drawn a picture there. I kept the picture in my zipped backpack the whole way home so the adult wouldn’t ask about it.
The stuffed rabbit from the other house was in my backpack too. At the red light, the adult asked, “Do you ever wish you lived at our house all the time?” I thought about saying yes because the adult was waiting. But I knew it wasn’t true, and I didn’t want to say no. So I looked out the window like I hadn’t heard.
“That’s okay. You don’t have to answer,” the adult said. The adult’s voice got quiet.
That night the adult knelt beside my bed and pulled up my blanket.
“Who do you like being with more?” the adult asked, the same way the adult would ask what I wanted for breakfast.
“I don’t know,” I said.
“You can tell me. I won’t be upset.”
The adult was already starting to smile, and I thought the adult was waiting for one answer. So I said, “You.” The adult kissed my head and turned off the light. I lay there in the dark and wished I hadn’t said it. When the door shut, I took the stuffed rabbit from the other house out of my backpack and held it under the blanket. Before it got light, I put the rabbit back in my backpack so the adult wouldn’t see I had slept with it.
I whispered “sorry” into my pillow. I was saying it to the other adult, who didn’t know I had said “You.”
On Friday the other adult came to pick me up. The adult was still packing my bag in the hall, and the other adult stood in the doorway.
“Which house do you want to be at this weekend? You pick,” the other adult asked.
“Maybe both houses could work?” I said. Nobody said anything. “Or whichever you want,” I said fast, to fill the quiet. The adult packing my bag stopped for a second, then zipped it. I looked at the zipper so I wouldn’t have to look at either of them. Then we went out to the front step. The two adults stood on either side of me and didn’t look at each other. I wished one of them would say something so I wouldn’t be standing in the middle. I kept my feet in the middle and my arms at my sides, so I wouldn’t lean toward either one. I hugged the one I was leaving first. Then I hugged the other one for just as long, so it would be even.
My water bottle was in my backpack too. “Tell them the water bottle has to come back washed,” the adult said quietly as I picked up my backpack.
“Okay,” I said. I got in the back seat of the other adult’s car and buckled up. The adult waved from the step. I waved out the back window until the car turned the corner, so the adult wouldn’t be standing there with nobody waving back. I never said the water bottle part at the other house. I thought the other adult would make a face and say something back, and then I would have to carry the message home.
So I washed the bottle myself in the sink and said nothing. The next Sunday, the adult was waiting on the front step and asked, “Did you tell them about the water bottle?”
“I forgot,” I said. It was easier than saying I didn’t want to.
“You can’t forget everything,” the adult said, and sighed.
I wanted to say I hadn’t really forgotten, but then I would have had to say why. Since then, when someone asks me to choose, even which cereal or which movie, I say, “I don’t mind.” Whenever I pick one, the adult I didn’t pick stops talking.
This morning in your kitchen I held out two cereal boxes.
“Will you pick one for me?”